It was a DVD. No case. Just the disc itself, rainbow-slick under the lamp. Someone had scrawled on it with a permanent marker:
Are you trying to find 2013-era independent films legally? hushawifeathomealone2013hothindimoviedvdrip
2013 thrillers often used grainy, atmospheric visuals (common in DVDrip quality) to heighten the sense of dread. Why Does It Still Have a Cult Following? It was a DVD